OpenAI's o1: Has It Surpassed Claude 3.5 Sonnet? Testing with Cursor

Developers Digest
12 Sept 202410:16

TLDRIn this video, the presenter explores OpenAI's o1 preview and o1 Mini models within the Cursor platform. Despite some rough edges and the requirement of OpenAI's tier five access, the video demonstrates how to integrate these models using an API key. The o1 Mini model outperforms the o1 preview in certain coding tasks and is more cost-effective. The video showcases the models' capabilities in generating web pages and UI components, highlighting the potential and limitations of these AI tools in web development.

Takeaways

  • πŸ˜€ The video explores the OpenAI's o1 and o1 Mini models within the Cursor platform.
  • πŸ” Only available to users with Tier 5 access to OpenAI, these models are not yet accessible to all.
  • πŸ’» Users can add the o1 model to Cursor by entering the model string manually.
  • πŸš€ The o1 Mini model outperforms the o1 preview for coding tasks and is more cost-effective.
  • πŸ› οΈ Cursor's composer feature allows for the creation of new files and understanding of file context.
  • πŸ“ The o1 model does not stream back responses, delivering them all at once instead.
  • πŸ’‘ The video demonstrates using the composer to transform a page into a landing page for 'Developers Digest'.
  • πŸ“ˆ There are some errors and rough edges with the o1 model, such as invalid JSX comments.
  • 🎨 The video also shows how to improve the page's aesthetics by adding color and a navigation bar.
  • πŸ“± The o1 Mini model is recommended for developers due to its speed and cost efficiency.
  • πŸ’Ό The video concludes with a discussion on the potential of these models and the need for further updates from Cursor.

Q & A

  • What is the main focus of the video?

    -The main focus of the video is to test the new OpenAI models, specifically the o1 preview and o1 Mini, within the Cursor code editor.

  • What is the current availability of the o1 models in Cursor?

    -At the time of recording, the o1 models are not available within Cursor's Pro tier and are only accessible to those with tier five access to OpenAI.

  • How can users add the o1 model to Cursor?

    -Users can add the o1 model to Cursor by going to Cursor settings, then adding a new model using the model string found in the URL bar or from OpenAI's documentation page.

  • What is a unique feature of the composer view in Cursor?

    -The composer view in Cursor creates new files and understands the context of what has been passed in, including different files and their contents.

  • Does the o1 model stream back responses?

    -No, the o1 model does not stream back responses; instead, it provides the full response after processing.

  • Which model, o1 preview or o1 Mini, performs better for coding tasks?

    -The o1 Mini model outperforms the o1 preview model for coding tasks and is also cheaper and faster.

  • What issues were encountered when using the o1 model with Next.js?

    -The o1 model made some errors, such as putting invalid comments within JSX and not being up-to-date with the latest Next.js practices, like the use of app router.

  • What is the cost implication of using the o1 models?

    -Accessing the o1 models through the API can be relatively expensive, especially for the o1 preview model, while the o1 Mini model is more cost-effective.

  • How does the video creator suggest using the o1 models in the development process?

    -The video creator suggests using the o1 models for tasks that require reasoning and not just instantaneous execution, and also leveraging other LLMs for other aspects of application development.

  • What is the current limitation of using the o1 models as per the video?

    -The current limitation is not the ability to execute but rather the ideas and how to effectively use the AI tools to ship applications quickly.

  • What does the video creator anticipate regarding the future availability of the o1 models?

    -The video creator anticipates that OpenAI will roll out the o1 models to more users with API keys and that the Cursor team will make it available to their Pro tier members.

Outlines

00:00

πŸ€– Exploring OpenAI's GPT-3.5 Models in Cursor

The speaker discusses testing out the GPT-3.5 models, specifically the 01 preview and 01 Mini, which have been recently released by OpenAI and integrated into the Cursor platform. These models are currently accessible only to those with tier five access to OpenAI. The video demonstrates how to add the model to Cursor settings and use it with an API key. The speaker notes some rough edges and anticipates future improvements. They also compare the 01 Mini model favorably to the 01 preview model in terms of performance and cost. The video includes a demonstration of using the Cursor's composer feature to generate a landing page for a hypothetical brand called 'Developers Digest', highlighting the model's ability to create new files and understand context.

05:02

πŸ› οΈ Enhancing Web Pages with Cursor's AI Assistance

In this part, the speaker continues to explore the capabilities of the GPT-3.5 models within Cursor, focusing on enhancing web pages. They use the composer to add new pages and improve the aesthetics of the existing ones. Despite some errors and the need for manual adjustments, such as removing an invalid comment and adjusting the layout, the speaker is generally pleased with the model's performance. They also discuss the cost implications of using these models via API, noting that while the 01 Mini model is more affordable, it's not the cheapest option. The speaker reflects on the model's training data, which is up to 2023, and its effectiveness in handling modern frameworks like Next.js, suggesting that there might be some confusion due to the rapid evolution of such technologies.

10:04

πŸŽ₯ Wrapping Up the Cursor and GPT-3.5 Experience

The speaker concludes the video by summarizing their experience with Cursor and the GPT-3.5 models. They express hope that the models will become available to a wider audience and that the Cursor team will continue to enhance the integration. The video ends with a call to action for viewers to like, comment, share, and subscribe if they found the content useful, hinting at the possibility of more content on this topic in the future.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘OpenAI o1

OpenAI o1 refers to a series of new AI models released by OpenAI that are designed to tackle complex problems. These models are capable of spending more time thinking before responding, which allows them to perform better in reasoning and handling scientific, coding, and mathematical tasks that are more challenging than previous models. The o1 series is seen as a significant advancement in AI capabilities, representing a new level of performance.

πŸ’‘Cursor

Cursor is an AI-first code editor that integrates with OpenAI's models to enhance coding efficiency. It offers features like intelligent autocompletion, multi-line editing, and AI-driven code generation, which can significantly speed up the development process. In the context of the video, Cursor is used to demonstrate the capabilities of the new OpenAI o1 model by generating and editing code within a project environment.

πŸ’‘API Key

An API key is a unique identifier used to authenticate requests to an API. In the video, having tier five access to OpenAI allows users to plug in their API key and utilize the new o1 models within Cursor. The API key is essential for developers to access and integrate advanced AI models into their applications.

πŸ’‘Composer View

The Composer View in Cursor is a feature that allows users to generate new files and understand the context of existing files. It creates a new file based on the user's input and the context of the project. This feature is highlighted in the video as a way to streamline the development process by automatically generating code and files based on the user's commands.

πŸ’‘Reasoning Models

Reasoning models, like the ones in the OpenAI o1 series, are designed to mimic human thought processes to solve complex problems. They are trained to think step-by-step, optimize their thinking process, and identify errors, which enhances their ability to handle tasks that require deep understanding and multi-step reasoning. The video showcases how these models can be used to improve coding and problem-solving in software development.

πŸ’‘Tier Five Access

Tier Five Access in OpenAI refers to a high level of access that allows users to utilize the most advanced AI models, such as the o1 series. This access level is not available to all users and typically requires a higher subscription tier or special permission. The video mentions that those with tier five access can use their API key to integrate the o1 models into their development environment.

πŸ’‘Model String

A model string is a unique identifier for an AI model that can be used to configure and integrate the model into a software application. In the video, the model string is used to add the o1 preview model to Cursor, allowing the user to access the advanced features and capabilities of the new AI model.

πŸ’‘Next.js Application

A Next.js application is a web application built using the Next.js framework, which enables functionality such as server-side rendering and generating static websites. In the video, the user demonstrates the integration of the OpenAI o1 model with a Next.js application to automate and enhance the development process.

πŸ’‘Invalid Comment

An invalid comment in the context of the video refers to a syntax error or inappropriate comment placement in the code generated by the AI model. The video points out that while the new models are powerful, they may still produce errors that need to be addressed by the developer, highlighting the importance of reviewing and validating AI-generated code.

πŸ’‘UI Components

UI components are the building blocks of user interfaces, such as buttons, menus, and forms. The video discusses the generation of UI components using the OpenAI o1 model and compares its performance with other models like Claude 3.5 Sonnet. It suggests that while the o1 model is capable, it may not be the best at generating UI components compared to other models.

Highlights

Testing OpenAI's o1 and o1 Mini models within Cursor.

Cursor Pro tier does not yet have access to these models.

o1 models are only accessible with OpenAI's tier five access.

Rough edges in the integration but expected to improve.

Instructions on how to add the o1 model in Cursor settings.

Demonstration of using the composer view to create a landing page.

o1 model does not stream back, providing full response at once.

o1 Mini outperforms o1 preview for coding tasks and is cheaper.

Initial page creation by the model and manual adjustments made.

Model created pages with basic structure and content.

Model generated an invalid comment in JSX.

Comparison of model capabilities in generating UI components.

Model's performance in creating professional-looking pages.

Model's training data is up to 2023, but Next.js knowledge seems limited.

Model failed to compile due to incorrect component imports.

Potential for Cursor team to optimize model integration.

Model's cost implications when accessed via API.

Recommendations for using AI tools in application development.

Final thoughts on the o1 models and their integration with Cursor.