AI VS Professor: Can ChatGPT Pass the Plagiarism Check?

Paper24com
6 Feb 202304:55

TLDRIn this video, the presenter explores how college professors detect plagiarism in student essays by using AI tools like ChatGPT and Quillbot to generate content. Despite passing Turnitin's originality test with a 13% similarity index, the essay is flagged as AI-generated by GPTZero. The presenter then uses Quillbot to rephrase the essay, achieving a 4% similarity index, but still fails the AI writing test. The video concludes by advising students to write their own work to avoid plagiarism detection.

Takeaways

  • 👨‍🎓 College students often seek the easiest way to complete assignments with minimal effort.
  • 👨‍🏫 Professors aim to ensure students put in genuine effort and earn their grades.
  • 🤖 AI tools like ChatGPT can write essays quickly, but their authenticity can be questioned.
  • 📝 Turnitin is a widely used plagiarism detection tool in educational institutions.
  • 📊 A similarity index under 13% is considered acceptable by Turnitin.
  • 🚫 GPTZero is a tool designed to detect AI-generated text, contrasting with ChatGPT's purpose.
  • 🔍 AI-generated essays can pass the originality test but may fail AI writing detection.
  • 📑 QuillBot is an AI rephrasing tool that can alter the original text's meaning.
  • 📉 Paraphrasing through AI can reduce the essay's quality and originality score.
  • ⏰ Editing AI-generated content to pass AI detection can be time-consuming.
  • ✏️ Writing original content is often more efficient than attempting to disguise AI-generated work.
  • 💡 ChatGPT is a valuable resource but should not be used to pass off AI text as original work.
  • 📚 Services like Paper24 offer original, human-written papers that can pass plagiarism checks.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video?

    -The main topic of the video is to explore whether AI-generated essays can pass plagiarism checks and how college professors detect such instances.

  • What is the purpose of using tools like ChatGPT and Quillbot in the video?

    -In the video, tools like ChatGPT and Quillbot are used to simulate a scenario where a college student might use AI to write an essay quickly and attempt to pass it off as original work.

  • What is the significance of the 13% similarity index reported by Turnitin?

    -A similarity index of 13% is considered acceptable for a student-submitted paper on Turnitin, meaning it would pass the originality test.

  • What is GPTZero and how does it differ from plagiarism detection tools?

    -GPTZero is a tool developed by the same founders as ChatGPT, but with the contrasting purpose of detecting AI-generated writing. It differs from plagiarism detection tools as it specifically checks for AI-generated content.

  • Why did the video creator decide to use QuillBot after using ChatGPT?

    -The video creator used QuillBot to rephrase the content written by ChatGPT in an attempt to lower the similarity index and potentially avoid detection by plagiarism and AI detection tools.

  • What was the outcome of the paraphrased essay when checked with Turnitin?

    -The paraphrased essay had a 4% similarity index, which is lower than the original 13% and also passes the originality test.

  • How did GPTZero evaluate the paraphrased essay?

    -GPTZero evaluated the paraphrased essay with a text perplexity of 11 and burstiness of 32, indicating that the text is most likely generated by AI.

  • What is the video's stance on using AI tools like ChatGPT for academic writing?

    -The video suggests that while AI tools like ChatGPT can be helpful resources, attempting to pass off AI-generated text as one's own work is likely to result in plagiarism detection.

  • What alternative does the video suggest for students struggling with essay writing?

    -The video suggests using services like Paper24, which provides original and human-written papers that pass all plagiarism detection tools.

  • What is the final message of the video to college students?

    -The final message is that while AI tools can assist in the writing process, students should consider the potential consequences of submitting AI-generated work and the time it might take to edit it to avoid detection.

Outlines

00:00

📚 College Plagiarism Detection

In this video, Vlad from Paper24 explores how college professors check for plagiarism in student papers. The video aims to understand the dynamics between students seeking shortcuts and professors ensuring academic integrity. Vlad first assumes the role of a student using AI tools like ChatGPT and Quillbot to quickly write an essay on 'Should a college education be free for students in the USA?'. The essay is then tested for plagiarism using Turnitin, which reports a 13% similarity index, considered acceptable. However, GPTZero, designed to detect AI-generated text, indicates a high likelihood of AI authorship. The video suggests that while AI tools can help, submitting AI-written content as original work is likely to be detected.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Plagiarism

Plagiarism refers to the act of using another person's work or ideas without giving proper credit to the original source. In the context of the video, it is the primary concern of college professors who want to ensure that students are submitting original work. The video discusses how plagiarism checks are conducted using various tools to detect copied content. An example from the script is the use of Turnitin, a plagiarism detection tool, to check the originality of a paper written by an AI, with a similarity index of 13% being considered acceptable.

💡Turnitin

Turnitin is a widely used plagiarism detection service by educational institutions to check the originality of students' submissions. It compares the submitted work against a vast database of academic papers, articles, and web content to identify similarities. In the video, Turnitin is used to check the AI-generated essay, and it returns an originality report with a 13% similarity index, which is deemed acceptable.

💡Originality Report

An originality report is a document generated by plagiarism detection tools like Turnitin that details the percentage of content in a document that matches existing sources. It is used to assess whether a student's work is original or contains plagiarized content. In the video, the originality report for the AI-written essay shows a 13% similarity index, indicating that the essay would pass a plagiarism check.

💡GPTZero

GPTZero is a tool designed to detect AI-generated text. It analyzes the text for certain characteristics that are indicative of machine-generated content. In the video, GPTZero is used to analyze the essay written by ChatGPT and determines that it is likely AI-generated based on the text's perplexity and burstiness scores.

💡Perplexity

In the context of the video, perplexity is a metric used by GPTZero to measure the complexity of the text. A lower perplexity score suggests that the text is more straightforward and likely generated by an AI. The essay's perplexity score of five indicates a high likelihood of AI generation.

💡Burstiness

Burstiness, as used by GPTZero, refers to the pattern of repetitiveness in the text. AI-generated texts tend to have bursts of repeated phrases or structures. In the video, the burstiness score of 17 for the AI-written essay further supports the conclusion that the text was generated by an AI.

💡QuillBot

QuillBot is an AI-powered paraphrasing tool that can rephrase existing text to create a new version that is semantically similar but structurally different. In the video, the college student uses QuillBot to rephrase the AI-generated essay in an attempt to pass plagiarism checks by altering the text's structure.

💡Paraphrased Essay

A paraphrased essay is a rewritten version of an original text that aims to convey the same meaning using different words and sentence structures. In the video, the student uses QuillBot to paraphrase the AI-generated essay to reduce the similarity index and potentially avoid detection by plagiarism tools.

💡Similarity Index

The similarity index is a percentage that represents how much of a document matches existing sources. A lower similarity index indicates a higher level of originality. After paraphrasing the essay with QuillBot, the similarity index drops to 4%, suggesting a higher degree of originality compared to the original 13%.

💡AI Writing Tools

AI writing tools are software applications that use artificial intelligence to assist in writing tasks, such as generating text, paraphrasing, or editing. In the video, ChatGPT and QuillBot are examples of AI writing tools that the student uses to quickly produce an essay. The video warns against submitting AI-generated content as one's own, as it can be detected by plagiarism tools.

💡Paper24

Paper24 is mentioned in the video as a service that provides original, human-written papers that are designed to pass plagiarism detection tools. It is presented as an alternative for students who are struggling with essay writing, suggesting that using such a service could result in a paper that avoids plagiarism detection.

Highlights

College students often seek to minimize effort while maximizing grades.

Professors aim to ensure students earn their grades through hard work.

The video explores using AI tools like ChatGPT to write essays and bypass plagiarism checks.

ChatGPT can produce essays that are difficult to distinguish from human-written ones.

TurnItIn is a widely used plagiarism detection tool in educational institutions.

A similarity index under 13% is considered acceptable for student papers on TurnItIn.

GPTZero is a tool designed to detect AI-generated text.

The essay generated by ChatGPT was flagged as likely AI-written by GPTZero.

QuillBot is an AI rephrasing tool used to modify the original AI-generated essay.

The rephrased essay had a lower similarity index on TurnItIn, indicating less originality.

GPTZero still identified the rephrased essay as likely AI-generated.

Editing an AI-generated paper to pass AI detection can be time-consuming.

Using AI tools like ChatGPT can be helpful, but copying and pasting can lead to plagiarism.

Paper24 offers original, human-written papers that pass plagiarism checks.

The video concludes by encouraging students to write their own papers to avoid plagiarism.